On Thursday of last week Mark and I presented at the Tech Com III - a venture capital / entrepreneurship event hosted by the Connecticut Venture Group . We talked about Higher One - from idea to profitibility, or, as I think I’ll talk about it from now on - From Olive Garden to Olives….
It was fun. Frank Marco - who’s been such a wonderful friend and resource as one of our attorneys for Higher One was the moderator for the panel. One of the questions he asked was about seed capital, and what he we thought Connecticut could do to help….
As I’ve been involved in the entrepreneurial scene in CT for more than 7 years, I’ve come to realize that there is one large misconception that is shared by a lot of people. Connecticut, as most people know, and Geico likes to remind us, is the richest state in the union. Since we’re not the most populous state, one can surmise that there must be many wealthy people in CT. The thinking then goes - aha - if we can get these wealthy individuals interested in angel investing, we’ll help stimulate connecticut’s technology economy - right?
In my opinion, that’s wrong. Angel investing, and more importantly, succesful angel investing, is not about having money (ok - if you don’t have money you can’t do it - but just because you do have money doesn’t mean you can or will). It’s about having an understanding of what you’re investing in, and how to best help that investment become a full fledged enterprise. First, there is a problem with what most folks in CT see as angel investing. When the company has revenue, a product on the market, and is looking for money to grow, that’s early stage investing. Angel investing is funding a team, or individual with a product, a business plan, and a compelling vision. Usually there should be a demo, or other forms of proof of concept. Perhaps they have letters of intent from potential customers… If it’s a web based business, perhaps a beta of the software has been scrapped together and there are usage and business model milestones that have been met (but without significant revenue).
Now there are some people in CT who do this sort of investing(AIF has some good people) - most are succesful entrepreneurs who understand that once they’ve invested they need to contribute their network and ideas to the founding team to help it move forward (the network is probably the biggest way to assist). Overall, however, people in CT have made their money through conservative businesses such as banking and insurance. How do you make money in those businesses - this is an over simplification - but generally you have a lot of money, invest it and make a little bit on a lot. These are very risk averse businesses (far from hi-tech companies) and thus people who have become accreditted through wealth they’ve created through their careers are not the most likely to jump into angel investing in hi tech startups.
Ok - so that’ s the problem. What can CT do. Here are some ideas
1. Create incentives to bring entrepreneurs to CT (tax credits for capital gains related to new businesses), free or cheap space (the incubator network is a good start)
2. Create incentives for angel investors to invest or also move to CT (again I’m sure certain tax incentives could be created)
3. Woo technology companies to base in CT where potential entrepreneurs may emerge from (look at how many software businesses have sprung out of Microsoft - also, San Diego’s whole biotech economy can pretty much be traced back to my acquaintance Tim Wollaeger and the folks at Hybritech.
There are probably more ideas - but the basic idea is that the best angel investors are entrepreneurs who created wealth through creating new businesses. They understand the risks, the work, and the potential rewards. Rather than trying to convert CT’s wealth to this type of early stage investor, I think the state should try to focus on how to create this type of person, keep him or her here, or woo him or her from other environs… after all, CT is a great place to live - why shouldn’t it be a great place to start-up.